Debunking 7 Common Myths About Dog Training

One of the most common training mistakes is the belief that forceful techniques—shouting, hitting, or using shock collars—will make a dog behave. In reality, these methods only create fear and damage the trust between owner and pet.

There are gentler, evidence‑based ways to shape your dog’s behavior. In this article, professional dog trainer and behavioral specialist Doggy Dan explains seven widespread myths and provides practical, humane alternatives.

Watch My Video: What NOT to Do When Training a Dog

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I’ll earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases and donate 10% of my earnings to animal charities.

1. Older Dogs Are ‘Set in Their Ways’ and Can’t Be Trained

The phrase “you can’t teach an old dog new tricks” is a myth. Older dogs are just as receptive to training as puppies—often more so—because they are less distracted and more motivated by reward. The key is using up‑to‑date, positive‑reinforcement techniques.

2. Shouting or Screaming at the Dog Is OK

Many owners think yelling will command attention, but dogs actually respond best to calm, consistent cues. Repeated shouting can cause your dog to ignore you entirely, undermining training progress.

3. Using a ‘Clicker’ Is Necessary for Successful Dog Training

Clickers can be a useful tool for marking desired behavior, but they are not mandatory. Clear verbal commands and immediate rewards can achieve the same results without the need for an additional device.

4. If a Dog Can’t Be Trained, Then Something’s Wrong With the Dog

There is no inherent defect that makes a dog untrainable. Persistent behavior problems often stem from inconsistent or incorrect training methods. With the right approach, any dog can learn.

5. To Gain a Dog’s Respect, You Must Physically Correct and Dominate Them

Physical force and intimidation create fear, not respect. Building a relationship based on trust and positive reinforcement leads to lasting obedience and a deeper bond.

6. A Dog Trainer Can Train Your Dog for You

Professional trainers provide guidance, but the owner’s commitment to practice and consistency is essential. A dog’s training success depends on the owner’s ongoing effort and relationship with the pet.

7. The Best Way to Stop Dog Barking Is Using a Shock Collar

Shock collars deliver painful electric shocks, causing fear, anxiety, and potentially harmful behaviors. They are ineffective for long‑term control and are widely condemned by veterinary and animal‑welfare organizations. Positive‑reinforcement methods—such as teaching a quiet cue and rewarding silence—are safe and proven alternatives.

What Is the Best Way to Train a Dog?

The most effective training relies on gentle, respectful, and reward‑based techniques. By establishing clear communication and consistent routines, you can help your dog thrive as a loyal companion.

Dog Training That Works!

I recommend visiting The Online Dog Trainer, where Doggy Dan explains common training pitfalls and demonstrates methods that yield real results. Watch his video CLICK HERE for a deeper dive.

Common Dog Training Mistakes to Avoid

Read my post on Top 3 Dog Training Mistakes New Dog Owners Make When Training at Home and explore the American Kennel Club’s guide on 5 Common Dog Training Mistakes to Avoid for additional insights.

More Information About Dog Training

• Help with Dog Training (31 Free Dog Training Tutorials)
• How to Control Dog Behavior: 5 Golden Rules
• Why Your Dog Won’t Listen
• 7 Myths About Dog Training: What NOT to Do
• Top 3 Mistakes New Dog Owners Make When Training at Home

I Donate to Animal Charities

Thank you for visiting. I donate 10% of my website’s profits to animal charities. If you find this content helpful, please share it with friends and family. For a list of supported charities, click HERE.